Post by moon on Mar 19, 2011 23:10:52 GMT -5
Clint was clearly manipulated by idol, we don't even know if he was the deciding person in kicking JC out. Scotty was also in that group and did NOTHING about it. I'm not going to get into because ive beaten this subject to death on many other sites...
Mk. My favorites or lack thereof have changed... ill just give a rundown of each contestant
Naima Adedapo- She is not good. Completely off pitch in numerous performances. But demographically speaking she makes the show more diverse. She deserves to go home next.
Paul Mcdonald- I just don't get him. Yeah his voice is different but honestly he didn't sound very good on wednesday. His movements on stage are very awkward..
James Durbin- I feel he has been riding the coat-tail of his background story. Yeah he has high functional autism, and tourettes. But it doesn't deserve special treatment. I think his singing voice is pretty irritating, and his screams are what he relies on.
Thia Megia- Pretty voice, pretty smile.. but is kind of a robot. She's 15 and barely shows any personality. She kind of peaked in hollywood week and has sung boring ballads since then.
Haley Reinhart- Very unique, bluesy, jazzy voice, but what is with her song choices? Alicia, then Leann rimes, then whitney. I feel she has potential if she just sings Stevie nicks or something and just annihilates it. Cause she's been on the chopping block every week.
Stefano Langone- He's definitely consistent. But unique? I don't think so. His latest performance was amazing, though.
Pia Toscano- Great voice, great looks, good stage prescense. But she's moved probably a total of 10 feet on stage from her 3 performances. Most consistent contestant.
Scotty Mcceery- He's good at what he does, I suppose. I'm afraid he's going to sound the same every week and I'm already sick of it.
Lauren Alaina- She has a very powerful tone but has trouble in the lower register. She also thinks very highly of herself.. when the judges give her critique she takes it very personally.. as if she's already won.
Jacob Lusk- Umm, yeah. His last 2 performances were horrific. How was he not in the bottom 3? I was offended by his rendition of "Alone" yet the judges seemed to like it, go figure
Casey Abrams- He's different. His top 24 performance and top 13 performance were very good. But on wednesday, he completely ruined a good nirvana song... He needs to get back to where he was.
So.. My favorites are Haley, Pia, Stefano, Lauren and Casey
Mk. My favorites or lack thereof have changed... ill just give a rundown of each contestant
Naima Adedapo- She is not good. Completely off pitch in numerous performances. But demographically speaking she makes the show more diverse. She deserves to go home next.
Paul Mcdonald- I just don't get him. Yeah his voice is different but honestly he didn't sound very good on wednesday. His movements on stage are very awkward..
James Durbin- I feel he has been riding the coat-tail of his background story. Yeah he has high functional autism, and tourettes. But it doesn't deserve special treatment. I think his singing voice is pretty irritating, and his screams are what he relies on.
Thia Megia- Pretty voice, pretty smile.. but is kind of a robot. She's 15 and barely shows any personality. She kind of peaked in hollywood week and has sung boring ballads since then.
Haley Reinhart- Very unique, bluesy, jazzy voice, but what is with her song choices? Alicia, then Leann rimes, then whitney. I feel she has potential if she just sings Stevie nicks or something and just annihilates it. Cause she's been on the chopping block every week.
Stefano Langone- He's definitely consistent. But unique? I don't think so. His latest performance was amazing, though.
Pia Toscano- Great voice, great looks, good stage prescense. But she's moved probably a total of 10 feet on stage from her 3 performances. Most consistent contestant.
Scotty Mcceery- He's good at what he does, I suppose. I'm afraid he's going to sound the same every week and I'm already sick of it.
Lauren Alaina- She has a very powerful tone but has trouble in the lower register. She also thinks very highly of herself.. when the judges give her critique she takes it very personally.. as if she's already won.
Jacob Lusk- Umm, yeah. His last 2 performances were horrific. How was he not in the bottom 3? I was offended by his rendition of "Alone" yet the judges seemed to like it, go figure
Casey Abrams- He's different. His top 24 performance and top 13 performance were very good. But on wednesday, he completely ruined a good nirvana song... He needs to get back to where he was.
So.. My favorites are Haley, Pia, Stefano, Lauren and Casey